Eyeliner is a must-have in every beauty lover’s collection, but with so many choices, finding the right one can be overwhelming. In 2024, the GOATED eyeliners aren’t just about bold pigment—they’re about all-day wear, zero smudging, and flawless application. Whether you prefer sharp wings or soft glam, we’ve got you.
In this guide, we’ve rounded up the top 3 eyeliners of 2024 after testing across formulas, wear tests, and user reviews. Let’s dive into the products that actually live up to the hype.
🧾 The Lineup: 3 Best Eyeliners of 2024
This post contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Learn more.
🥇 1. NYX Epic Ink Liner
Best for Precision & Definition
Best For: Bold cat eyes, sharp wings, smudge-proof looks
Highlights: Ultra-precise felt tip, vegan formula, waterproof
Why It’s the Best:
NYX Epic Ink Liner is the ultimate drugstore holy grail. The felt tip glides effortlessly, creating super crisp lines with deep pigment. It’s waterproof, smudge-proof, and perfect for long days or dramatic evenings.
User Review:
“Rain, sweat, tears—this stuff stays PUT. Obsessed with the tip!”
✅ Pros:
- Inky black payoff
- Ultra-precise felt tip
- Affordable and cruelty-free
❌ Cons:
- Can bleed if too much pressure is used
- Cap can dry out if not secured properly
Verdict:
🔥🔥 Certified GOATED – Best eyeliner for bold precision and clean wings.
🥇 2. Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner (Blackest Black)
Best for Bold, Long-Lasting Looks
Best For: Smoky eyes, all-day glam, bold liner addicts
Highlights: Matte gel formula, brush included, waterproof
Why It Hits:
Maybelline’s gel eyeliner is the underdog that performs like a high-end formula. It’s intensely pigmented, lasts for hours, and is perfect for waterlines or smudgy liner looks. It resists smearing even in humidity.
User Review:
“This doesn’t move until I take it off with remover. Love it for inner corners too.”
✅ Pros:
- Long-wearing and waterproof
- Great for dramatic styles
- Easy to apply with angled brush
❌ Cons:
- Takes practice if you’re used to pens
- Can dry out if not sealed tight
Verdict:
🔥🔥 Certified GOATED – Best gel eyeliner for staying power and intensity.
🥇 3. Maybelline Unstoppable Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil (Onyx)
Best Budget Pick
Best For: Waterlines, lower lash lines, soft smudged looks
Highlights: Self-sharpening, long-wearing, classic formula
Why It Works:
Maybelline Unstoppable has stood the test of time. It delivers bold pigment and decent wear time, all at a super accessible price. Great for beginners or daily wear.
User Review:
“Cheap, dependable, and it doesn’t irritate my eyes. Win-win.”
✅ Pros:
- Affordable
- Easy to use
- Multiple shade options
❌ Cons:
- Can fade on oily lids
- Not as precise for winged looks
Verdict:
🔥👍 Budget Favorite – Best entry-level eyeliner for everyday use.
📣 Bonus Mentions
- Inglot AMC Gel Liner #77 – Legendary pigment but dries quickly.
- KVD Tattoo Liner – Still iconic but pricier than NYX for similar effect.
- Tarte Double Take – Dual-ended magic for liner lovers who want it all.
📌 Final Verdict
Top Recommendation:
If you’re chasing that ultra-sharp wing or liner that won’t budge after brunch and a breakup, go with NYX Epic Ink Liner. It balances price, pigment, and precision like a pro. For gel lovers? Maybelline’s Drama Gel is your best bet.